What's wrong with a Judge and Prosecutor getting a little friendly? Should that sort of relationship be disclosed when the prosecutor works in that court prosecuting cases? Is the fact that a secret relationship exists make a difference as to the outcome of the cases that are tried in that court? Should the public know about this if the case is a misdemeanor? Does a more serious case have more serious consequences?
How would you feel if you were convicted of crime and later found out that the judge and prosecutor were involved in a sexual relationship?
Well, apparently in Texas, these issues make no difference as to whether or a person convicted of Capital Murder will get a fair trial. Hey, as long as he was convicted what difference does it make that the judge and prosecutor were sleeping together, talking about the case during intimate moments or planning their strategy about how rulings at trial would occur.
It's called a conflict of interest, ex parte conversations, collusion and conspiracy and it should be morally wrong if not outright illegal . . . but not in Texas.
The Court of Criminal Appeals has said that all of this is OK and it's the defendant's fault for not bringing this to light sooner. Even though the judge and prosecutor lied about their relationship for several years, until their depositions were ordered and they decided they better fess up. Still, the CCA said that too much time had gone by for the defendant to get a new, fair trial because he should have brought this to light sooner.
HOW?
A sad commentary on the state of our judiciary can be found by clicking here.
Once the cone of silence breaks on this type of illicit conduct, then numerous cases are subject to review. It only takes time for that one person to come forward and tell what they have seen or known was going on for a long time. It only takes one disgruntled former ADA or person on the Judge's staff to complete that affidavit and then all sorts of cases will come under review for this type of sordid behavior to come out. Maybe someone has a photograph or video that sheds light on the affair or personal knowledge that it was going on.
In whatever manner it is finally disclosed, eventually it will be disclosed and then the entire criminal justice system is sullied for the sake of the egos of two very small people.
I bet this sort of thing happens more often than the public could imagine. It will be interesting to see whether or not this will be condoned at the federal level after the case is appealed. I can't imagine that a federal court would turn a blind eye and sanction this activity.