Result Summary for Survey:Montgomery County Judicial Survey

Montgomery County Judicial Survey

1. Judge Fred Edwards of the 9th Judicial District Court.
	answered question				30
	skipped question				3
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	10.0% (3)	63.3% (19)	26.7% (8)	2.17	30
Rules decisively and timely?	20.7% (6)	51.7% (15)	27.6% (8)	2.07	29
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	10.7% (3)	28.6% (8)	60.7% (17)	2.50	28
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	17.2% (5)	41.4% (12)	41.4% (12)	2.24	29
Works hard and is prepared?	14.3% (4)	57.1% (16)	28.6% (8)	2.14	28
Overall rating?	10.0% (3)	56.7% (17)	33.3% (10)	2.23	30

2. Judge Suzanne Stovall of the 221st Judicial District Court.
	answered question				31
	skipped question				2
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	50.0% (15)	36.7% (11)	13.3% (4)	1.63	30
Rules decisively and timely?	46.7% (14)	40.0% (12)	13.3% (4)	1.67	30
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	73.3% (22)	13.3% (4)	13.3% (4)	1.40	30
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	53.3% (16)	33.3% (10)	13.3% (4)	1.60	30
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	33.3% (10)	50.0% (15)	16.7% (5)	1.83	30
Works hard and is prepared?	40.0% (12)	46.7% (14)	13.3% (4)	1.73	30
Overall rating?	50.0% (15)	33.3% (10)	16.7% (5)	1.67	30

3. Judge Cara Wood of the 284th Judicial District Court.
	answered question				23
	skipped question				10
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	8.7% (2)	34.8% (8)	56.5% (13)	2.48	23
Rules decisively and timely?	13.0% (3)	65.2% (15)	21.7% (5)	2.09	23
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	13.0% (3)	60.9% (14)	26.1% (6)	2.13	23
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	13.0% (3)	30.4% (7)	56.5% (13)	2.43	23
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	8.7% (2)	34.8% (8)	56.5% (13)	2.48	23
Works hard and is prepared?	13.0% (3)	52.2% (12)	34.8% (8)	2.22	23
Overall rating?	4.3% (1)	47.8% (11)	47.8% (11)	2.43	23

4. Judge Kathleen Hamilton of the 359th Judicial District Court.
	answered question				27
	skipped question				6
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	14.8% (4)	55.6% (15)	29.6% (8)	2.15	27
Rules decisively and timely?	11.1% (3)	51.9% (14)	37.0% (10)	2.26	27
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	37.0% (10)	37.0% (10)	25.9% (7)	1.89	27
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	7.4% (2)	44.4% (12)	48.1% (13)	2.41	27
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	0.0% (0)	29.6% (8)	70.4% (19)	2.70	27
Works hard and is prepared?	30.8% (8)	57.7% (15)	11.5% (3)	1.81	26
Overall rating?	3.7% (1)	66.7% (18)	29.6% (8)	2.26	27

5. Judge K. Michael Mayes of the 410th Judicial District Court.
	answered question				25
	skipped question				8
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	58.3% (14)	25.0% (6)	16.7% (4)	1.58	24
Rules decisively and timely?	68.0% (17)	24.0% (6)	8.0% (2)	1.40	25
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	52.0% (13)	28.0% (7)	20.0% (5)	1.68	25
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	60.0% (15)	24.0% (6)	16.0% (4)	1.56	25
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	65.2% (15)	13.0% (3)	21.7% (5)	1.57	23
Works hard and is prepared?	80.0% (20)	12.0% (3)	8.0% (2)	1.28	25
Overall rating?	52.0% (13)	36.0% (9)	12.0% (3)	1.60	25

6. Judge Tracy A. Gilbert of the 418th Judicial District Court.
	answered question				10
	skipped question				23
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	60.0% (6)	40.0% (4)	0.0% (0)	1.40	10
Rules decisively and timely?	60.0% (6)	40.0% (4)	0.0% (0)	1.40	10
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	60.0% (6)	40.0% (4)	0.0% (0)	1.40	10
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	50.0% (5)	50.0% (5)	0.0% (0)	1.50	10
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	50.0% (5)	50.0% (5)	0.0% (0)	1.50	10
Works hard and is prepared?	60.0% (6)	40.0% (4)	0.0% (0)	1.40	10
Overall rating?	60.0% (6)	40.0% (4)	0.0% (0)	1.40	10

7. Judge Michael Seiler of the 435th Judicial District Court.
	answered question				24
	skipped question				9
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	4.3% (1)	47.8% (11)	47.8% (11)	2.43	23
Rules decisively and timely?	13.0% (3)	60.9% (14)	26.1% (6)	2.13	23
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	20.8% (5)	45.8% (11)	33.3% (8)	2.13	24
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	12.5% (3)	25.0% (6)	62.5% (15)	2.50	24
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	16.7% (4)	54.2% (13)	29.2% (7)	2.13	24
Works hard and is prepared?	13.0% (3)	47.8% (11)	39.1% (9)	2.26	23
Overall rating?	8.3% (2)	50.0% (12)	41.7% (10)	2.33	24

8. Judge Dennis Watson of County Court at Law Number 1.
	answered question				24
	skipped question				9
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	58.3% (14)	37.5% (9)	4.2% (1)	1.46	24
Rules decisively and timely?	70.8% (17)	25.0% (6)	4.2% (1)	1.33	24
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	66.7% (16)	25.0% (6)	8.3% (2)	1.42	24
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	52.2% (12)	39.1% (9)	8.7% (2)	1.57	23
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	66.7% (16)	20.8% (5)	12.5% (3)	1.46	24
Works hard and is prepared?	66.7% (16)	29.2% (7)	4.2% (1)	1.38	24
Overall rating?	70.8% (17)	20.8% (5)	8.3% (2)	1.38	24

9. Judge Jerry Winfree of County Court at Law Number 2.
	answered question				23
	skipped question				10
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	39.1% (9)	34.8% (8)	26.1% (6)	1.87	23
Rules decisively and timely?	39.1% (9)	39.1% (9)	21.7% (5)	1.83	23
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	56.5% (13)	30.4% (7)	13.0% (3)	1.57	23
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	43.5% (10)	26.1% (6)	30.4% (7)	1.87	23
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	50.0% (11)	31.8% (7)	18.2% (4)	1.68	22
Works hard and is prepared?	31.8% (7)	45.5% (10)	22.7% (5)	1.91	22
Overall rating?	43.5% (10)	30.4% (7)	26.1% (6)	1.83	23

10. Judge Patrice McDonald of County Court at Law Number 3.
	answered question				22
	skipped question				11
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	31.8% (7)	50.0% (11)	18.2% (4)	1.86	22
Rules decisively and timely?	50.0% (11)	50.0% (11)	0.0% (0)	1.50	22
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	68.2% (15)	22.7% (5)	9.1% (2)	1.41	22
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	50.0% (11)	31.8% (7)	18.2% (4)	1.68	22
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	40.9% (9)	45.5% (10)	13.6% (3)	1.73	22
Works hard and is prepared?	54.5% (12)	45.5% (10)	0.0% (0)	1.45	22
Overall rating?	40.9% (9)	50.0% (11)	9.1% (2)	1.68	22

11. Judge Mary Ann Turner of County Court at Law Number 4.
	answered question				23
	skipped question				10
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	30.4% (7)	56.5% (13)	13.0% (3)	1.83	23
Rules decisively and timely?	43.5% (10)	47.8% (11)	8.7% (2)	1.65	23
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	73.9% (17)	21.7% (5)	4.3% (1)	1.30	23
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	50.0% (11)	18.2% (4)	31.8% (7)	1.82	22
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	43.5% (10)	43.5% (10)	13.0% (3)	1.70	23
Works hard and is prepared?	50.0% (11)	45.5% (10)	4.5% (1)	1.55	22
Overall rating?	39.1% (9)	56.5% (13)	4.3% (1)	1.65	23

12. Judge Keith Stewart of County Court at Law Number Five.
	answered question				20
	skipped question				13
	Outstanding	Acceptable	Poor	Rating Average	Response Count
Follows the law?	78.9% (15)	21.1% (4)	0.0% (0)	1.21	19
Rules decisively and timely?	68.4% (13)	31.6% (6)	0.0% (0)	1.32	19
Is courteous and attentive toward attorneys and witnesses?	95.0% (19)	5.0% (1)	0.0% (0)	1.05	20
Demonstrates impartiality (e.g. without regard to party, contributions, race, gender, or other bias)?	90.0% (18)	10.0% (2)	0.0% (0)	1.10	20
Uses attorney's time efficiently?	95.0% (19)	5.0% (1)	0.0% (0)	1.05	20
Works hard and is prepared?	89.5% (17)	10.5% (2)	0.0% (0)	1.11	19
Overall rating?	84.2% (16)	15.8% (3)	0.0% (0)	1.16	19

�